Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Court reviews whether trial court properly dismissed a case as a result of a forum selection clause.

TENNESSEE RIVER COLLECTION YACHT SALES, LLC, ET AL. v. P.F.C., INC. dba STINGRAY BOAT COMPANY (Tenn. Ct. App. September 29, 2009)

This case arises out of the termination of a dealer agreement ("the Agreement"), pursuant to which Tennessee River Collection Yacht Sales, LLC, and TRC Watersports Center, LLC (collectively "the Dealers") were authorized to sell recreational boats manufactured by P.F.C., Inc. dba Stingray Boat Company ("the Supplier"), a South Carolina corporation. The Supplier terminated the Agreement citing the Dealers' failure to purchase the current product models. The termination was also based upon the recommendation of the Supplier's representative following an on-site visit to the Dealers.

The Dealers filed suit alleging that the Supplier's refusal to repurchase the Dealers' remaining inventory of Stingray boats was a violation of statutory law governing the "Repurchase of Terminated Franchise Inventory," the Code Commission-supplied label for Tenn. Code Ann. sections 47-25-1301 - 14 (2001) ("the Repurchase Act"or "the Act"). The Supplier filed a motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction, asserting that under a governing law and forum selection clause contained in the Agreement, the action had to be brought in South Carolina, not Tennessee. The trial court agreed and dismissed the complaint without prejudice. The Dealers appeal. We affirm.

Opinion may be found at:
http://www.tba2.org/tba_files/TCA/2009/tennesseeriver_092909.pdf